Homemade Butterfinger Candy

Homemade Butterfinger takes just a
few simple ingredients!

In my never-ending quest for candy recipes, I was delighted to come across this one for Butterfinger,  & knew I had to try it! (Another Pinterest find!)  It only takes a few ingredients and was actually pretty easy. I didn't use the same chocolate as the original recipe because I prefer a mix of my own.... but basically it's the same recipe.



Ingredients:

2 1/2 cups candy corns (16 oz. bag)

1 cup crunchy peanut butter

1 cup semi-sweet morsels

1 cup milk chocolate morsels

STEP 1: Melt candy corn in a glass bowl at 30 second intervals, stirring after each, until completely melted.

STEP 2: Add in peanut butter. Mix thoroughly.



The candy centers, as they cool.

  STEP 3: Pour into a prepared 8"x8" pan, lined with foil and sprayed with a non-stick cooking spray, like Pam.



Cut into longer bars or just into bite-sized pieces.

STEP 4: Allow to cool to room temperature. Once cool, cut into bars or bite-size pieces. Refrigerate in a ziplock bag for 2 hours, or until cold and firm.

STEP 5: Microwave 1/2 cup semi-sweet & 1/2 cup milk chocolate morsels in a glass bowl, for 30-second intervals, until melted. Stirring after each 30 second interval.

STEP 6: Prepare your dipping area: Place a sheet of waxed paper or parchment paper on a cookie sheet. Get out your candy centers that were placed in the refrigerator. Bring your bowl of hot, melted morsels to your dipping area, along with 2 dinner forks. (Yes, dinner forks!)



Just dipped Butterfinger candies...not quite dry!

STEP 7: Working quickly, drop your first candy center into the bowl of melted chocolate. Using a fork, flip the candy over to coat other side. If any candy is still exposed, use your fork to push some chocolate over the exposed areas. Obviously, any area not covered with chocolate now, won’t be covered later. I use two forks now, and once I have lifted the candy up with my right fork, I gently tap that fork on the side of the bowl to help any dripping chocolate to fall back into the bowl, and I then go to place the candy on the parchment or waxed-paper covered tray, using my left fork to help to slide it off, trying not to damage the chocolates’ surface too much. (To view photos of this method, click here.)

*This is not a professional approach to candy dipping, by any means. There are candy-dipping ‘forks’ and other useful utensils available at most craft stores. For technique, you may want to peruse some websites that have step-by-step photos or even a video. I use this method because the Internet was not around when I first started making candy! I gleaned what I could from every book, article and recipe and came up with this method, which works for me.



All finished & ready to eat!

STEP 8: Continue working until all candies are coated with chocolate. If your candy centers start to seem a bit soft, just place them back in the refrigerator, or only take a few out at a time. Again, remember to work quickly since your chocolate is easiest to work with when warm and will become harder and harder to work with as it cools down. If your chocolate does become too hard to work with, simply reheat at 30 second intervals. One or two 30-second zaps should be all that’s necessary. Once your chocolate supply seems too shallow in your bowl, use the remaining morsels, melt in microwave & continue to coat the remaining candies.

STEP 9: Let cool in refrigerator, or if you’re in a hurry, the freezer works great! Once your chocolate has set, remove from tray and place in an air-tight container. I like to place small pieces of waxed paper between each candy. I then place them back in the refrigerator. 

ENJOY!

Interested in other Homemade candy recipes? Click here to try Twix or Peppermint Patties.